|
|
| Jainism compared with Buddhism |
|
|
Jainism
Jainism or Jain Dharma (जैन धर्म) is an ancient religion of India that prescribes a path of non-violence
(Ahimsa) towards all living beings. Jain philosophy is based upon eternal, universal truths. During the first and
last two Aras, these truths lapse among humanity and then reappear through the
teachings of enlightened humans, those who have reached moksha or total
knowledge (Kevala Jnana), during the third and fourth Aras. Traditionally, in
our universe and in our time, Lord Rushabha (ऋषभ) is regarded as the first to
realize the truth. Lord Vardhamana (Mahavira) was the last Tirthankara to attain
enlightenment (599-527 BC). He was preceded by 23 others, making a total of 24 Tirthankaras. A Jain is a follower of Jinas
The goal of Jainism is to realize the soul's true nature. "Samyak darshan gyan charitrani
moksha margah", meaning "true/right perception, knowledge and conduct" ( known
as the triple gems of Jainism) provides the path for attaining liberation
(moksha) from samsara (the universal cycle of birth and death). |
 |
|
Jaina tradition identifies Bhagwan
Rishabh (Adhinath) as the First Tirthankar. There are five basic ethical principles (vows) prescribed in
Jainism as Non-violence (Ahimsa), Truth (Satya), Non- stealing (Asteya), Celibacy
(Brahmacarya) and Non-possession (Aparigraha). According to Jain philosophy,
there is no supreme divine creator, owner, preserver or destroyer. The universe is self-regulated and every soul has the potential to achieve divine consciousness (siddha) through its own
efforts. Every living being has a soul. Every soul is the architect of its own life, here or
hereafter. Every soul is born as a celestial, human, sub-human or hellish being according to its own
karmas, When a soul is freed from karmas, it becomes free and attain divine
consciousness. The goal of Jainism is liberation of the soul from the negative effects of unenlightened thoughts, speech and action..
Jains do not believe in an omnipotent supreme being, creator or manager (kartā), but rather in an eternal
universe governed by natural laws. |
|
|
Buddhism
Buddhism is a religion preached by Goutama Buddha. He was a contemporary of Lord
Mahavira who was the 24th Thirthankara of the
Jainas. Goutama Buddha belonged to the Sakya clan of warriors. The warrior
class of Sakyas claim their connection
with the families of the great Ekshvaku dynasty.
Goutama Sakhya Muni was born to a king by
name Suddhodana whose capital was Kapilavastu. Goutama Sakhya Muni was born in B.C.
623. At the time of his birth, the sooth- Sayers and astrologers predicted that he would renounce the world
and becomes a great religious teacher. In
order to prevent such an event, his father arranged to bring up his son practically in seclusion from the general world so
that no dark side of life can appear before him. He was married and
a son was born to him. Though his father
had arranged to keep him always in happy
environment, Goutama Buddha arranged with
his charioteer to take
him out of the place along the thoroughfares of the City. There he met the real
life of the people. One day he met an old man. At another time he met a corpse
carried in a bier. He learnt from his
charioteer that old age, disease and death are the inevitable consequences of life. He learnt to his utter disappointment that his life as a happy youth
surrounded by similar youthful and happy men and women must
inevitably pass through the old age and end in death. He naturally thought about the vanishing
youth. He began to contemplate on the misery of life all around and he wanted to
investigate why there should be misery in the world
and what was its true cause. was it not possible to avoid this dreadful misery? If it was
possible to avoid and extricate misery, what was the proper method for achieving this
end? Thus he began to think of Dukha, Dukhotpati,
Dukha Nirodaha and Dukha Niroda Margaha. While contemplating on
these four important aspects of life - Buddha decided that
in order to achieve his purpose he must renounce the world once for all.
With this decision, one night he instructed his
charioteer to drive him beyond the palace and the City to the forest. There he
removed all his ornaments and the royal robes and gave them to his charioteer, who was asked to return
to the City. Himself remaining in the forest as an ascetic, he went upon
solving the problem of misery which the world is so full of. He tried the various
methods of performing Thapas as practiced by the various groups of ascetics whom he met. He
was not satisfied with all methods. He did not relish the extreme practices. He
chose for himself the middle path avoiding extremes of
self mortification. Accepting the moderate and sober method of yogic contemplation,
he was able to see beyond the veil which hid the face of reality. While sitting under a Bodhi tree, he secured
the yogic enlightenment or wisdom. He became the Buddha - the enlightened one. |
Gutama Siddhârtha
Life: BC. 563-483, BC. 463- 383 (Died at the age of 80)
Birth Place: Lumbini Garden in Kapilavastu
Parents: Shuddhodana, Mâyâ (died 7days after the birth) Marriage: Marry Yashodarâ at age of 16
Son: Râhula
Enlightenment: After 6 years of penance and meditation
begun Buddha, under Ashvattha (Bodhi) tree by the river Nairanjanâ near Gayâ
Place of first sermon: Sârnâth (Migadâya, Deer park) |
|
Having secured
the knowledge of the nature of life, he set out to preach to the people the truth that he
himself acquired through yogic
contemplation. The first place
he visited was Banaras. It was a great religious center
even in his days. There he preached
his Dharma which was based upon
Ahimsa or Non-violence to the learned men there.All of them appreciated his principle of Dharma and became his
disciples. Thereafter he went from place to place
with his disciples. The number of his followers was
increasing day by day till several thousands accepted
his faith. Several persons
followed him after renouncing their home and became the ascetics. Thus the monks
organized a distinct group
from their lay followers. After sometime, he admitted women also in the ascetic order. Thus a separate group of
female ascetics or nuns was also organized. These
ascetic groups of monks and nuns
Bhikshus and Bhikshinis formed a Sanga or the Order of ascetics. Thus arose the 3 great venerable institutions of
Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. In the
course of their time, these 3 were considered of great importance and Buddhistic laymen and ascetics
began to worship these 3 jewels - Buddha, Dharma and Sanga.The Philosophy of Buddhism
According to the philosophy of Buddhistic school,
the nature of reality is constituted by 5 Skandas. These are
Rupa, Vigyana,
Sagna and Samskara skandas. These are further sub-divided into
various kinds. Rupa Skanda refers to physical
objects. All physical objects
belong to the class of Rupa Skanda. These physical
objects are otherwise called
Ashtaka or of 8 elements. These are the 4 Bhuthas - earth, water, air and fire and the four
corresponding sense qualities - Varna, Rasa,
Gandha and Sparsa - colour,
taste, smell and touch respectively. A mass made of these 8 elements is called
Ashtaka.
These are momentary existences. The group
appears at one moment
and completely disappears the next moment. The second
Vedana Skanda is the element
of feeling. It is of 3 kinds - Sukha Vedana, Dukha
Vedana and Samavedana which
are respectively called the feeling of pleasure, the feeling of pain and the neutral
feeling. These are caused respectively by the 3
kinds of Samskaras - Kusala - right conduct, Akusala - wrong conduct and Sama
Samskara - neutral activity. Thenext is Vigyana
Skanda or the element of knowledge. This is of six kinds. The 5 sense
experiences together with Manas constitute the six Vigyana Skandas - elements.
Corresponding to these 6 kinds of Vigyana Skandas,
there are six kinds of three kinds - Manasika, Vachika and Kayika - activity related to thought, word and deed respectively.
These 5 Skandas have his characteristic. They appear together and get destroyed together in a moment. Their
behavior is analogous to a flame of light. It
is kind of Ashtaka Pinda. The 8 elements constituting the
flame of light appear and disappear momentarily and yet, the continuity of the flame is
maintained. Similar is the behavior of the 5 Skandas. They appear
and disappear every moment. Yet, they produce the appearance of continuity of things in this world. Besides these 5
constituent elements Skandas, there is no such
thing as a persistent substance. The idea of permanent substance is due to
ignorance of the nature of reality according to Buddhistic
philosophy. When you close your fingers tightly, you call it by name fist. But there
is no substance called fist apart from the 5 fingers. When you stretch out your fingers,
there is no fist. Similarly,
when you assemble the various building materials into a structure, you give it the
name of a house. But where is the house apart from the building materials? To talk of fist apart from fingers
and to talk of a house apart from building materials, is to
exhibit one's own ignorance
as to the nature of things. Similarly, apart from the
5 Skandas which constitute
the Purusha, there is no independent reality called
Atma. These 5 Skandas which
constitute the reality have the following characteristics -
Anitya,
Dukha, Asuchi and Anatma. They are Anitya because they are momentary and vanishing, they
are Dukha because they are by
nature painful, they are
Asuchi because they are impure and they are devoid of
underlying substratum hence called
Anatma. One who realizes the true nature of
reality will be free from evil, escape from Samsara and will attain Nirvana.
This in short is the philosophy and religion of Buddhism.
Different Views
This view of reality is
rejected by the Jaina thinkers because
Buddhism cannot logically maintain this
Kshanika Vada or the momentary existence of the
reality.The momentary series of
experiences since it is not based upon the
underlying substratum, becomes a series of
disconnected items merely a juxtaposition
and having no connection with each other. There can be no causal
connection between one item and the succeeding
one in the series. Unless you assume the ultimate
identity between the antecedent and the consequent,
you cannot explain why a
particular antecedent should be
succeeded by a relative identical consequent. If human personality is reduced to a disconnected series of Skandas,
there is no moral justification for preaching the Dharma
and acting according to it. The entity acting according to Dharma vanishes in a moment and the entity
that enjoys the fruits of action is quite different from the actor. The final liberation
or Moksha called Nirvana implies mere cassation of the series. It is compared to a flame that
is put out. There is nothing left thus in the external physical world as well as the
internal psychic series.
Both have nothing as their basis. Thus the Buddhistic
philosophy ends in Nihilism. The exact parallel to this in
western philosophy is Hume's Nihilism. By a
similar process of logic, Hume reduces the external world
and also personal consciousness to the series of sensations and ideas having nothing behind them.
While rejecting the Buddhistic metaphysics, Jaina
thinkers accept the ethical code prescribed by Buddhism. Both the schools strictly observe
the principle of Ahimsa and reject the Varnashrama Dharma as a
social organization. In
maintaining the principle of nonviolence, Buddhism in the course of its history, has
deviated from the real path. It justifies meat eating so long as one does
not kill the animal for his food but purchases meat from the butcher. In the same way, Jaina Darsana
in the course of its history compromises its attitude towards Varnashrama
Dharma. The Jainas appear to have assimilated various social customs resulting from
Varnashrama distinctions, thus each has deviated from its original purity.
Both schools suffered during
the period of the Hindu revivalism. Due to religious intolerance and
persecution. Buddhism was completely exterminated
and Jainism was reduced as a faith of a small minority. |
|